Back to assessments
Source assessmentContext only

A 21st-Century Ethical Hierarchy for Robots and Persons

Ethical hierarchy for robots and personsAcademicdocument

Assessment outcome

total 1/4 (actionability 0 + authority 1); currency unscored, so pro-rated to 1.5/6

Total1/6
Actionability0/2
Authority1/2
Currency—

Authorship & scope

Attribution (G4 evidence)

The source clearly identifies Selmer Bringsjord as the author of the chapter.

Issuer authority (evidence)

Level 1: Published as an academic book chapter by Springer, representing a reputable academic institution/publisher.

Issuers, who it governs, legal force and content are on the full record.

Eligibility gates

G1 · Retrievablepass

HTTP 200, 2480 words of full text extracted

G2 · AI nexuspass

The primary subject is robot ethics and whether robots can be moral, constituting a clear AI nexus.

G3 · Governance nexuspass

The source explicitly discusses legal obligations, ethical hierarchies, and rules for autonomous agents.

G4 · Attributablepass

The source clearly identifies Selmer Bringsjord as the author of the chapter.

G5 · In forcepass

There is no indication on the page that this version has been superseded, withdrawn, or repealed.

Scored criteria

Actionability

0/2

Level 0: The text offers conceptual analysis of an ethical hierarchy and deontic logics without prescribing binding steps.

Authority

1/2

Level 1: Published as an academic book chapter by Springer, representing a reputable academic institution/publisher.

In: Aldinhas Ferreira, M., Silva Sequeira, J., Tokhi, M., E. Kadar, E., Virk, G. (eds) A World with Robots.

Currency

—

computed: no publish/modified date found on the page (never guessed)

Classification

Coverage topicEthical hierarchy for robots and persons
PerspectiveAcademic
Lifecycle stage1 Plan & design
Layerboth
Granularitydocument