Back to assessments
Source assessmentContext only

Guilty Robots? - Rethinking the Nature of Culpability and Legal Personhood in an Age of Artificial Intelligence

Culpability and legal personhoodAcademicdocument

Assessment outcome

total 1/4 (actionability 0 + authority 1); currency unscored, so pro-rated to 1.5/6

Total1/6
Actionability0/2
Authority1/2
Currency—

Authorship & scope

Attribution (G4 evidence)

Named authors are clearly identified.

Issuer authority (evidence)

Level 1 (capped): the quote establishes a journal venue but does not establish the peer-review status required for Level 2.

Issuers, who it governs, legal force and content are on the full record.

Eligibility gates

G1 · Retrievablepass

HTTP 200, 379 words of full text extracted

G2 · AI nexuspass

The source is entirely about artificial intelligence and robotics.

G3 · Governance nexuspass

It specifically discusses criminal liability, culpability, and legal personhood.

G4 · Attributablepass

Named authors are clearly identified.

G5 · In forcepass

No indication of being superseded or repealed.

Scored criteria

Actionability

0/2

Anchor 0: Description or analysis only, examining criminal liability and legal personhood of robots without imposing binding steps.

Authority

1/2

Level 1 (capped): the quote establishes a journal venue but does not establish the peer-review status required for Level 2.

Journal Criminal Law Forum Type journal article Date Issued 2018-12-04 Author(s) Simmler, Monika ; Markwalder, Nora DOI 10.1007/s10609-018-9360-0

Currency

—

computed: no publish/modified date found on the page (never guessed)

Classification

Coverage topicCulpability and legal personhood
PerspectiveAcademic
Lifecycle stage7 Use & impact
Layermodel
Granularitydocument